The debate between the two sci-fi franchises has raged on for decades. The question is which is more realistic – Star Wars or Trek? The two franchises share a number of similarities, including diverse casts, rich mythologies, and a symbiotic relationship. So which came first? We look at the answers below to find out. Read on to discover the answers to these burning questions!
Table of Contents
Star Wars is more realistic
The most obvious comparison between Star Wars and the original Star Trek is the time factor. The original series had a much longer run than the later movies, but Star Wars has caught up to Trek with cartoons like “Clone Wars” and rumors of a live action TV series. That said, both series have their strengths and weaknesses. Hopefully, the “Clone Wars” movies will live up to their predecessors in the near future.
Star Trek shows are much more realistic because they deal with long-range space combat, while Star Wars is based on space fantasy. In addition, the naval battles in Star Wars are modeled after the engagements of World War II battleships. Star Wars is more grounded in reality. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages. However, both series have the potential to be successful as long as the audience is willing to invest in them.
Star Trek is more realistic
Despite its optimistic and futuristic setting, Star Trek is more realistic than some of its fans might think. While Voyager, Discovery, and Deep Space Nine were all set in future worlds, these shows often portray our future politics in a more realistic way. The Klingon Empire, for example, attacked Cardassia without warning and allied itself with the Federation. And in Star Trek, we see people carrying out the Federation’s values, whether they’re good or bad.
Another difference between Star Wars and Star Trek is the level of realism in space battles. In Star Trek, for example, ships fly at speeds of over 0.1c. That means that fast-moving mass transforms into plasma in the atmosphere, rendering them virtually undivertible. Star Wars, by contrast, uses birdshot style railguns and fanciful weapons to kill enemy spaceships. Even computers have a hard time discerning when a ship is passing another.
Both franchises have a diverse cast
If you’re looking for inspiration in television and films, look no further than Star Wars and Trek. Both franchises feature diverse casts. The original Star Trek, released in 1978, was the first television show to feature a black woman in space. Mae Jemison, who played Uhura on the show, was inspired by the Civil Rights Movement. She was the first black woman in space, and her skin tone is similar to that of Nyota Uhura.
The new Star Wars movies and television series are a testament to Hollywood’s commitment to diversity. The film franchise has featured prominent black and Asian characters, and both “Star Wars” and “Star Trek” have included a number of female characters. Even the Star Wars films have had their share of black actors. While many of the characters in these franchises are white or male, Star Wars has made strides to represent all types of people.
Both franchises have a symbiotic relationship
There is a deep connection between Star Wars and Star Trek. Both franchises feature utopian societies and a powerful, yet unlikely, rebellious force. In fact, they both influenced George Lucas when he was writing the script for Star Wars. The franchises’ similar themes and world-building make them both essential viewing. But they also have their share of ambiguity and contradictions.
One way to understand how both franchises relate to each other is to look at the arc of their characters. While the characters are often similar in character, the stories are quite different. Often, the series takes a different approach to exploring contemporary issues. For example, a recent episode of Star Trek dealt with capitalism and drug addiction. For one episode, an entire planet profited from the addiction of another. A comparison of Brekkians and Ornarans is particularly interesting, since one planet had developed a civilization and industries based on felicium, while another world only had a felicium industry.
Both franchises have spanned decades
While both franchises are revered for their philosophical approach to sci-fi, the latter has done much to popularize the genre. Indeed, both franchises owe their continued existence to each other, as George Lucas and William Shatner both admitted. In fact, both men said that they only saw Star Wars as a viable franchise after it became popular in 1977. It’s also interesting to note that both Star Wars and Trek have had more sequels than any other franchise, demonstrating their long-term popularity.
The Star Wars franchise is an obvious example of this phenomenon. Its characters, setting, and universe have lasted decades. But the Trek movies are a different story. They’re both entirely fictional and set in locations far removed from real-time. The Trek films focus on a human race that is constantly in conflict with aliens, and the Star Wars franchise features no such conflict. However, both franchises are incredibly popular, and fans have become accustomed to seeing new characters pop up.