Is it possible that Emily killed Alison? She stabbed her, rejected her, and then faked her death to get out of the spotlight and find her? Here are some theories. Which of these theories is true? Read on to find out. What’s the real motive behind Alison’s murder? Did Emily stab her? Did she fake her death to escape detection? And what about the third A? Will Alison’s death change the relationship between Emily and Nick?
Table of Contents
Emily kills alison
In the book “Emily Kills Alison”, the Liars suspect “A” when they find Alison dead. Alison has a number of identities, so when the Liars first discover that Alison is dead, they suspect “A”. Eventually, the Liars cycle through the suspects to find the real murderer. Emily’s true motive is not yet revealed, but her motivations for murder are largely unclear.
Emily began to love Alison during their seventh grade class, and she fantasizes about her being alive. She is so obsessed with Alison that she nearly attempts suicide, but her friends convince her that “A” is dangerous. After seeing Jordan die, she is haunted by Alison’s murder. In addition, she hates Alison because she saved her from the fire. Despite her love for Alison, Emily is unable to move on without her ex-boyfriend, Jordan.
She rejects her
In “Emily Rejects Alison,” Alison tries to convince Emily to have a baby by telling her that she’s pregnant. Alison knows that the baby is not hers, but she wants to be just like Emily. Paige says that she can understand why Ali is upset about her pregnancy. Ali agrees. Emily, however, is not so understanding. She tells Alison that she’s planning a baby and she’ll think about it.
At Alison’s house, Emily comes over and asks for the key to Spencer’s barn. She thinks that Addison is a ploy from Jenna, but she wants to see proof that A.D. is behind this. Alison isn’t sure that A.D. is behind all of this, and she doesn’t take her questions seriously. However, Emily informs Alison that she thinks Addison is making inappropriate accusations about her. She thinks she’s only trying to wear Alison down.
She stabs her
As the book begins, the two girls are visiting Nick in prison. Nick tells the girls that he has heard from Alison’s grandma that she will kill Alison if she ever returns. The girls are horrified by the news and Emily vows revenge. The girls also discover that Alison was involved in the murder of her boyfriend. After the girls’ return, Nick is in prison too. But, before he can kill Alison, Emily must first find the girls.
In the episode “A,” the third ‘A’ is a terrifying creature who tortures the girls about difficult situations. The apparition is more violent than the previous two. The girls discover that the ‘A’ is the same person who murdered Alison and Tabitha, as well as three other people. Emily, however, does not realize that her mother is the one who killed her daughter. The third ‘A’ is determined to stop Emily from killing Alison, and she stabs her to death in an attempt to kill her.
She fakes her own death to fly under the radar to find her
In Deadly, Emily fakes her own death to go undercover in order to track down Alison, a young girl she has lost touch with. She is a high-school dropout who is going through a difficult time in her life, and her death will send shockwaves throughout Rosewood. Despite her insecurities, Emily is determined to find her long-lost sister and end the years of harassment and abuse. During her search for her sister, she finds out that her twin sister is in a mental hospital.
Alison had been pestering Alison and Emily for money before she was dead. It was obvious she was in desperate need of money, so her attempts to swindle people for money were in support of her faking death plan. It was not the truth that she had lost, but she wanted to leave behind a beautiful corpse that would be easy to find. But, before she could kill herself, she lied and blackmailed Hector Lime and Byron for hundreds of dollars.
She drugs her
In the episode “Emily killed Alison because she drugs her,” Spencer tells Aria that she believes Alison almost killed her, but that is just fiction. Alison, meanwhile, has been meeting with many people and wore a bright yellow shirt the night before. Spencer, on the other hand, is taking upper pills and doesn’t know why he’s been waking up so early.
Spencer is also jealous of Paige’s friendship with Emily. He believes that Emily is her friend and he won’t let her know what Alison has been up to. However, Paige, who’s still in love with Alison, isn’t so sure. After all, Emily is the one who killed Alison, so why should she tell Paige? She doesn’t know, but Paige plays along with Emily, who knows it’s a lie.
She stabs a stalker to death
In ‘Emily St. Germain, stabbed to death by Emily N. – a former stalker – Emily stabbed Dhruv to death with a knife that she used to stab herself. Thankfully, her parents found her and sent her to therapy for her prettiness-induced rage. Emily was suffering from a serious case of prettiness fatigue – a condition that only affects SUPER PRETTY people. It was so debilitating that Emily wanted to kill someone, even if it was to hurt someone’s feelings.
The case is complicated by the fact that Ludwick had previously claimed to have helped Joran van Der Sloot dispose of Natalee Holloway’s body and was now being sued for murder. John Ludwick was the suspect in this case, but Emily claimed to have stalked him for months. It wasn’t until he tried to stab her repeatedly that she realized what was happening.